When to Stop Teaching

Good teaching ends earlier than teachers expect. The last lesson is the one where you say nothing.

Teaching notes · 316 words

Every teaching relationship has a natural end, and it is almost always earlier than the teacher expects. The sign is not that the learner has mastered the game. The sign is that the learner has started asking questions the teacher did not plant, and that their questions have become more specific than the teacher's answers.

At that point, more teaching becomes interference. The learner needs room to build their own sense of a route, and a teacher in the room changes what they attempt. Every advice given becomes a rule followed, and rules followed too early are how a player ends up with habits they did not choose.

So the last lesson should be a lesson in stepping back. Play one round together with the teacher making no comments, no hints and no faces. Afterwards, ask one question: what did you notice? Then stop. The question is the last piece of teaching, and the silence after it is the lesson.

The second half of stopping well is making sure the learner does not depend on the teacher's presence to show up. A daily game is the perfect structure for this because it does not require anyone else. The learner should leave with one habit, not with a practice partner. If they play tomorrow, the teaching worked. If they only play when reminded, the teaching was companionship, which is a different and also fine thing.

One good test of the ending: if you are away for a week, the learner should not need to ask what to do.

Practically, hand over the useful links and then disappear: the game page for the daily board, one hint at a time for when they are stuck, and the rest of the site for whatever they discover. A learner with three links and no teacher will learn more in a month than a learner with a teacher and a schedule.