Demonstrate, Don't Explain

A two-minute demo with commentary teaches a route better than any description of route-building.

Teaching notes · 300 words

After the rule, demonstrate. Do not solve the puzzle for the learner; solve a visible portion of it while narrating only the decisions that could have gone another way. The difference between demonstrating and explaining is that a demo shows a board changing, and boards are what learners remember.

The narration is the delicate part. If you narrate every move, the demo becomes a performance and the learner watches instead of thinking. If you narrate none, the moves look arbitrary. The useful middle is to narrate the one or two junctions where you had a real choice, and to say out loud what you rejected. "I could have changed the last letter here, but that would have taken me into a corner of the word list I could not leave" is a sentence a new player can use tomorrow. A commentary on total move count is not.

It also helps to show one failed branch on purpose. Choose a branch you already know is a dead end, spend one move on it, then back out and explain what the wall looked like. New players believe that experienced players do not hit walls. They do; they just leave faster. Seeing a wall handled calmly is more useful than seeing a perfect route.

Keep the whole demo under two minutes and end it in the middle. Ending before the route finishes leaves the learner wanting the rest, which is exactly the condition you want on day one.

When the demo is over, don't take the board away. Let the learner try the same start from the top, and stay quiet while they do. A good moment to hand over the board is the switch to play unlimited, where a fresh start removes the feeling that there is one correct way to continue.