Hints as a Teaching Tool

Used correctly, a graded hint is a coaching question. Used carelessly, it is the end of the lesson.

Teaching notes · 313 words

A graded hint system is an unusually good teaching device because it asks for patience from both people. The first level points at a letter or position. The second reveals a single word. The third describes the shape of the route. Each level corresponds to a different kind of stuck, and matching the level to the stuck is a skill worth teaching explicitly.

The lesson to teach is: take the smallest hint that moves you. A learner who jumps to the second level because the first level felt vague has not given the first level a real chance. Five minutes with a direction hint, on a board that is genuinely stuck, is the most productive five minutes a beginner can spend, because it keeps the route in their own hands.

The second lesson is to test the hint. After taking a direction, guess what it implies before acting on it. "If the first letter is the problem, then changing it to a vowel probably opens more words than changing it to a consonant." Say the guess out loud, then test it on the board. This converts the hint from an answer into a hypothesis, which is the difference between a tutorial and a lesson.

The third lesson is restraint on the teacher's side. When a learner is stuck, the temptation is to supply the word because it is faster. Faster is the wrong objective here. The teacher's job is to keep the board in front of the learner while they work, not to make the route shorter.

Model the discipline yourself. On the next round, take one hint level out loud and let the learner watch how little it gives away. When they want a bigger practice space, the unlimited ladder lets you both play the same rule without sharing a board, which is often the best arrangement for a mixed-level pair.